| Pos | Fresh El-Caminos | thedeuceisloose.com | Mountaineer Mania |
| QB | Elvis Grbac (KC) | Daunte Culpepper (Min) | Rich Gannon (Oak) |
| QB | Gus Frerrotte (Den) | Steve Beuerlein (Car) | Brett Favre (GB) |
| RB | Mike Anderson (Den) | Marshall Faulk (Stl) | Charlie Garner (SF) |
| RB | Lamar Smith (Mia) | Jerome Bettis (Pit) | Emmett Smith (Dal) |
| RB | Terry Allen (NO) | Warrick Dunn (TB) | Fred Taylor (Jax) |
| RB | Edgerrin James (Ind) | Ron Dayne (NYG) | Mike Alstott (TB) |
| WR | Eric Moulds (Buf) | Cris Carter (Min) | Antonio Freeman (GB) |
| WR | Tim Brown (Oak) | Az-Zahir Hakim (Stl) | Herman Moore (Det) |
| WR | Amani Toomer (NYG) | Jerry Rice (SF) | Shawn Jefferson (Atl) |
| WR | Torry Holt (Stl) | Jacquez Green (TB) | Terry Glenn (NE) |
| WR | Rod Smith (Den) | Tony Gonzalez (KC) | Keenan McCardell (Jax) |
| K | Mike Hollis (Jax) | Joe Nedney (Car) | Morten Andersen (Atl) |
| K | Martin Gramattica (TB) | Jeff Wilkins (Stl) | Mike Vanderjagt (Ind) |
| D/ST | St. Louis (Stl) | Pittsburgh (Pit) | New Orleans (NO) |
| D/ST | Detroit (Det) | Tennessee (Ten) | Baltimore (Bal) |
| FLEX | Brian Griese (Den) | Brad Hoover (Car) | James Thrash (Was) |
| FLEX | Marcus Robinson (Chi) | Wayne Chrebet (NYJ) | Albert Connell (Was) |
| Pos | AFC Smackem Yackem | Ally-Cats | Slaughter Savages II |
| QB | Kurt Warner (Stl) | Aaron Brooks (NO) | Jeff Garcia (SF) |
| QB | Steve McNair (Ten) | Mark Brunell (Jax) | Shaun King (TB) |
| RB | Curtis Martin (NYJ) | Jamal Lewis (Bal) | Robert Smith (Min) |
| RB | Jamal Anderson (Atl) | Ricky Watters (Sea) | James Stewart (Det) |
| RB | Corey Dillon (Cin) | Eddie George (Ten) | Tiki Barber (NYG) |
| RB | Thomas Jones (Arz) | Stephen Davis (Was) | Tyrone Wheatley (Oak) |
| WR | Keyshawn Johnson (TB) | Marvin Harrison (Ind) | Terrell Owens (SF) |
| WR | Raghib Ismail (Dal) | Donald Hayes (Car) | Mushin Muhammed (Car) |
| WR | Ed McCaffrey (Den) | Jimmy Smith (Jax) | Derrick Alexander (KC) |
| WR | Terrence Wilkins (Ind) | Derrick Mason (Ten) | David Boston (Arz) |
| WR | Randy Moss (Min) | Joe Horn (NO) | Isaac Bruce (Stl) |
| K | Sebastian Janikowski (Oak) | Ryan Longwell (GB) | Jason Hanson (Det) |
| K | Matt Stover (Bal) | Gary Anderson (Min) | Jason Elam (Den) |
| D/ST | Jacksonville (Jax) | Miami (Mia) | Tampa Bay (TB) |
| D/ST | Kansas City (KC) | Denver (Den) | Washington (Was) |
| FLEX | Vinny Testaverde (NYJ) | Peyton Manning (Ind) | Tshimonga Biakabutuka (Car) |
| FLEX | Ricky Dudley (Oak) | Trent Green (Stl) | Charlie Batch (Det) |